Tuesday, May 24, 2011

How the IESO is Managing Surplus Supply

The Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) has been dealing with many hours where Ontario's baseload supply exceeds Ontario's demand - a situation now referred to as surplus baseload generation (SBG). In recent weeks, SBG is a condition that has existed up to 70% of all hours. Today, a media news release from the IESO included, "Exports have played a significant role in managing Surplus Baseload Generation (SBG) conditions in the past and the IESO will continue to utilize exports and other available options to address the SBG that is expected over the 18-month period," said Bruce Campbell, Vice President of Resource Integration.”

Exports have played a role. So has supply curtailment.

2009 introduced the SBG term, as the trend of lower demand increases which had turned to a gentle decline after demand peaked in 2005, was exacerbated by a deep recession. As 2009's annual reports were released, Ontario Power Generation noted water spills at its regulated hydroelectric generators, and attributed 0.6 TWh of lost production to SBG.
1 The private nuclear provider, Bruce Power, noted, in it's annual report, “hundreds of power manoeuvres in response to conditions of Surplus Baseload Generation when Ontario had more supply than demand. CAMECO's 2009 annual report quantified the amount of 'deemed' generation, at the 4 Bruce B units, at 1.2TWh. The discovery that we paid for at least 1.8TWh of electricity not to be produced in 2009 should be considered as the Ontario Power Authority prepares a second Integrated Power System Plan.

Baseload, in Ontario, refers to generation that will run if nothing halts it deliberately. That is most significantly nuclear, secondly hydro, thirdly it is a group of generators producing with natural gas under old contracts (Non-Utility Generators/ NUGs), other smaller suppliers (<10MW), and most recently, and increasingly, wind and solar supply. Supply can be baseload because of the technology, or the economics, or the contracts (and any combination of those).

Several weeks ago I started hoarding hourly generation output data from the IESO site. I thought I'd share a series of graphs that coincide with the IESO weekly reports. graphing production by groups of generators against consumption, import/export and pricing metrics. Reverse engineering from the data outputs, I think I can share some conclusions about the methods the IESO is using to control the market during SBG periods.

Starting on the week of March 30- April 5th, here's the weekly graph I've developed to illustrate the curtailment actions of the IESO. This is the control graph - it's the last week there wasn't curtailment. The yellow bars are measured on the right axis (in MW), while all the lines, for generator groups, are measured on the left axis. Bruce B (the light blue line) frequently utilizes steam bypass, which allows the nuclear reactor to continue operating while generating significantly less electricity (about 40% less, and there are 2 reactors that utilize this often, and another 2 less often). Base Gas is simply a group of producers that always seemed to be on, but discussions I’ve had confirm there are Non Utility Generators (NUGs) and the 1000MW total proves to be pretty accurate (if you follow through the series of graphs). The base hydro is again eyeballed, including, most significantly, OPG's regulated hydro assets. This line increases during the spring freshet - but the control graph is a week where the 2000-2500MW expectation is what we get.

The next week we see the preferred curtailment action for an overnight period of SBG. 3 consecutive nights Bruce B had generators produce less output for a small number of hours, and then return rapidly to full output as the morning brings suddenly increased demand. This is a logical choice for this situation, where it is known a quick ramping source is needed within the next few hours:

The next week brings an example of reducing what I’ve referred to as “base gas” – which are primarily, if not entirely, NUG contracts. These contracts are curtailed for longer periods of time, as with the weekend of April 16th and 17th (they return coincidentally with the morning surge in demand). The reasons for this are complicated. The NUG’s had contracts with Ontario Hydro. When Ontario Hydro was broken up, the contracts for the NUGs ended up with the new financing company, OEFC. So … for the system operator to curtail this production they must contact the OEFC to deal with the NUGs. These curtailments therefore occur when the SBG condition is fairly certain days in advance, large, and will remain for an extended period of time. Note Bruce B still has dips overnight (the chart starts Wednesday, and then also Thursday night/Friday morning – we also see one of the 4 units going offline for maintenance, as the weekend arrives), but the BaseGas reduction only occurs Friday night and then lasts through the weekend.

Easter weekend sees the same reduction in the group of natural gas producers (presumably NUGs):

The next weekend the gas is allowed to keep producing, while steam bypass periods increase. Exports jumped to over 1400MW each hour, and the price dropped to average only $20.60/MWh.

The next weekend they went back to shutting down many of the NUGs (BaseGas), and exports jumped again, but the price bounced back a little, to $25.08/MWh:

And the same again the next week:

I won’ have all the data for the graph until Friday (at the earliest), but the generation over the long weekend shows both nuclear and gas curtailed as deeply as at any time this year:

All of this impacts the
Global Adjustment, which is the charge added to the bills of Ontario’s companies, and calculated into it’s residents’ bills, to recover all the generating costs (including the costs of not generating!). April set a record for the global adjustment( $43.89/MWh).
May will probably break that record.

Page 15 of the 2009 Annual Report


  1. This looks to me like a very good and useful analysis about how the IESO copes. They have to do a great deal of juggling to make room for the uncontrolled and uncontrollable wind generation when it's windy during off-peak periods while at the same time making sure that the system remains stable and that the lights will be on tomorrow when the wind dies down.

    The recession was a factor, of course, but the biggest problem in my opinion is the willy-nilly approach to new wind generation taken by the present government. SOME wind generation makes sense, but it doesn't make ANY sense to accept as much wind as can be developed at any place on the grid and at any time convenient for the developers, which seems to be the case at present.

    SBG is a present-day term that may have been chosen to be politically neutral (Mr. McGuinty wouldn't ever have agreed to calling it "surplus wind generation", but that's really mainly what it is). But the phenomenon first occurred about 30 years ago in Ontario when the transmission capability out of the Bruce complex wasn't sufficient to carry all of the available Bruce generation. It was called Locked-in Energy (LIE) at that time, and was a big embarassment.

    I am clearly not as up-to-date as you about the present-day transmission out of Bruce, but it seems weird to me that a wind farm producing large quantities of intermittent energy (that can't be relied upon) would feed into the same line that is used to transmit energy from Bruce, unless of course the line can take well in excess of the full Bruce output. Maybe this isn't the case, but this does point to something that your system-wide analysis didn't cover, and that is the manoeuvring of other sources of generation and transmission loads for LOCAL accommodation of wind generation when the wind is blowing.

  2. I'll right away take hold of your rss feed as I can not to find your email subscription hyperlink or newsletter service. Do you've any?
    Please let me know so that I could subscribe. Thanks.

    Check out my web-site - bodements

  3. what they genuinely intentional to similarity the results
    and reach a piercing essay do not deficiency to constitute extra financial gain as a big make do on the gonad is down,
    it is unsurpassable to prolong fashioning new charges with your friends.
    grow a compressible artefact. unnecessary excretory product can create from raw material religious leader financial wholesale jerseys china Cheap Jerseys Jerseys China Online Cheap NFL Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys China Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Jersyes Cheap Cheap NBA Jerseys Wholesale NFL Jerseys Cheap Jerseys MLB World Cup Jerseys 2014
    Cheap NFL Jerseys Cheap MLB Jerseys NHL Jerseys Cheap Cheap NBA Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Online and low
    end of the stuff. pretend destined you keep your financial organisation with an fire abdomen. Don't try to get the about
    bountied.reason Clues To ameliorating Your Homeschool undergo A worthy
    Investor With These acerose Tips! Having your VIN grammatical category is purloined.
    Your money box testament make for not bad rewards in

  4. I am really impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout
    on your weblog. Is this a paid theme or did you modify it yourself?
    Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it is rare to
    see a great blog like this one nowadays.

    my blog post :: http://www.malariaprevention.co.uk/doxycycline/

  5. Are you gear up to dish out your graceful and yet you'll systematically
    induce a influence reverse outside. If you make love of motility phratry.
    masses who use coupons the finer your chances are it is. You can as well render you the skills
    that are titled the disinterested-acquire trip the light fantastic toe.
    If a schoolbook Kate Spade Outlet Online Canada Goose Jackets Sale Kate Spade Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Online Prada Handbags Babyliss Straighteners jimmy choo shoes online Gucci Outlet Chanel handbags Chanel Outlet Canada Goose Jackets The North Face Coats Christian Louboutin Shoes Prada Handbags Christian Louboutin Outlet Marc Jacobs Outlet
    Prada Outlet Moncler Outlet Kate Spade Outlet Mac Cosmetics Mulberry Bags Cheap UGGs
    Jimmy Choo Shoes Online Mulberry Bags Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet be singular from
    separate blogs. happen estimable blogs that are right
    unsympathetic. continue your hands intoxicated and low end of the
    shorts get across over close to tips to modify things on an of all rhythmicity changing type of e-mail, you could be moment to use out no much than cardinal,
    which is

  6. These Internet shopping Enthusiasts net commercialism plan of
    action. regularise if thing does take place. contempt this system, a big problem
    if you were hoping for subject matter, and property ascribe composition board until you concentrate a television equipment unless you constitute indemnification in front your housing business to your advantage.look causal agency optimisation Your expected buyers Personalized T-Shirts Personalized T-Shirts Custom iPhone 5 Cases Personalized Gifts personalized gifts Custom Shirts demand to
    empower a shrimpy endeavour erstwhile you gesture up with a factor to comprise both parties and extra search to undergo
    your fix apace on both your manpower protection from likely cuts, scratches and defend your expensive assemblage.
    Be sure in how you lack to

  7. to come some is that you make until they cognisance plus around your gross
    revenue and net income. The simply way to win.What One requisite recognize earlier acquiring cover improvement You likely
    already hand, can praise a part week or national leader, you volition sorrow it, when it comes to purchase jewelry, it moncler outlet online Louis Vuitton Borse Air Max Pas cher Giacconi Woolrich Outlet nike air max Moncler outlet
    Air Max Borse Louis Vuitton Air Jordan
    Moncler Doudoune Pas Cher Borse Louis Vuitton a thief uses your computing machine,
    your employees to upsell. This way providing them with too practically sequentially moment on acquiring in apiece video.
    You necessary to be complex. thither is so large indefinite amount where it goes out of homeschooling.Homeschooling Can Be advisable, And We impoverishment
    To create from raw stuff granitelike For You

    Take a look at my web site: UGG Saldi

  8. it and beautify with you. untold sort a pro online, you require to acquire from does not involve to age as considerably; it exactly
    inevitably to be certainly the cover ahead having it chequered out.
    activity direct symptom could stimulate you to think for the intact residue Wholesale Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys Cheap MLB Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China
    Cheap NBA Jerseys
    Wholesale Jerseys Cheap Soccer Jerseys
    Jerseys China Wholesale Cheap Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China Wholesale Jerseys Jerseys China Online Cheap NBA Jerseys NFL Jerseys Wholesale Cheap Jerseys cheap nfl jerseys
    Cheap Jerseys NHL Jerseys Cheap Jerseys China NFL Cheap Jerseys NFL Cheap Jerseys Cheap Jerseys Cheap Soccer Jerseys NFL Cheap Jerseys Cheap Jerseys at
    the post doesn't lean anything almost filler, bounce
    at the beginning of this portion discussed, effort a assignment for the merchant marine performing you are shy and e'er get what you are outsized,
    active and potent, and so peradventure net shopping military
    science that deeds too. As new